Why being better won't win you clients in a crowded market
When your skill keeps rising and your margin keeps falling, you are reading how crowded your market is, and the fix sits in your position.
Being better at the work stops winning you more clients once your market gets crowded, because the buyer can't see who is better, and because by then your margin is measuring how crowded the market is. When an owner asks me how to stand out in a crowded market, this is usually the last thing they were hoping to hear. Most of them have spent years getting better at what they do, and they assumed the reward for that would keep showing up in their sales. In a young market it often does. Once the market fills up, the link between craft and growth weakens every year, and most owners don't notice it breaking until they have worked hard for a long stretch with less to show for it.
The margin was measuring the market
I learnt this in the IT company I founded in my early twenties. When I began, anything that cost me $100 I could sell for $300, and that held across products and services alike. By the time I sold the business, the same $100 of cost sold for about $110. Over those years I hadn't got worse at anything. I knew the products and the clients far better than I had at the start, and I could quote and fix things much faster with stronger people around me.
Think about what that does to the arithmetic. At $300 I kept $200 on every $100 of cost, and at $110 I kept $10, which means I needed twenty sales to earn what one sale used to earn me. What had changed was how many people were doing the same thing, as more providers came in and buyers found more ways to solve the same problem. What I sold went from rare to ordinary while I was busy getting better at it, so my skill went up and my margin went down, and the two had very little to do with each other.
Your margin works a bit like a thermometer hanging in your market. It reads how many people are offering something that looks like yours and how easily a buyer can find them, and it takes no reading of you at all. When the number falls, most owners take it as a judgement on their work, which is a bit like blaming yourself because the thermometer says it's cold outside. Every market moves through the same stages, discovery, growth, saturation, commoditisation and re-engineering, and the first four happen to a market whether you're ready or not. Re-engineering is the only stage a business chooses, and choosing it is what resets the curve for that business.
Why owners polish the work when growth slows
When sales slow down, the natural response is to get better and work harder, because that is what got you here. In your early years, every improvement you made to the work showed up somewhere, in referrals or in what you could charge, so you learnt that craft pays. I call the belief that this will keep working the better trap. It feels responsible and it keeps you busy, and the problem is that the buyer has no way of seeing who is better. From the outside, most providers in a crowded market look roughly alike, so the improvement you spent a year on never reaches the place where the buying decision gets made.
Mortgage broking shows the trap clearly. It is about as crowded as markets get, and nearly every ad says some version of the same thing: thinking of refinancing, I can do 5.41 per cent. For a broker, being better means finding a lender who will go a little lower, so for a few weeks the ad says 5.39 instead. That is the easiest move in the market to copy, it comes straight out of the broker's margin, and it trains every buyer to judge brokers on the single measure that makes them all look the same.
Working harder, for the broker, means more ads and more follow-up calls aimed at anyone with a loan, and every one of those hours is real. None of them changes what the buyer sees, which is another broker with roughly the same rate as the last one. When a buyer can't see a difference, the only thing left for them to compare is the price, and competing on price is exactly how $300 turns into $110 over a few years.
Look at your position before your craft
Your skill still matters, because it is what lets you deliver well once someone has chosen you. The trouble is that it does very little to get you chosen in a market where buyers can't tell providers apart. What gets you chosen is your position, and the two parts of it I would look at first are who your offer is for and what the buyer compares it with. In a crowded market those decide your growth far more than your craft does, and far more than your marketing does too.
Blockbuster and Netflix are the cleanest public example I know. The video rental businesses that copied Blockbuster, Hollywood Video among them, were watching their competitor and running their own version of the same stores. Netflix was watching what customers might want if someone gave them an easier way to get a film, so it rented films through the post and later streamed them, and buyers stopped comparing it with a video store at all. It never had to beat Blockbuster at running video stores.
The smaller version of the same move is open to any owner. Choose a corner of your market small enough that very few providers there look like you, and the buyers inside it stop lining you up against everyone else, because there's nobody quite like you to compare you with. Turning other work away will feel expensive at the time, and it's usually the reason the move works. You own a small corner first, and then you move out from it.
This week, pull out your margins from the last few years and set them beside how much better you have become at the work. If your skill has gone up while your margin has gone down, you have been taking the thermometer's reading personally. Then write down, in your buyer's own words, what they compare you with before they choose you. If the plain answer is a list of providers who sound just like you, another year of polishing will feel productive and change very little, and the work worth doing is on your position.
Questions owners ask
- Why is my business not growing when I'm better at the work than ever?
- In a crowded market, buyers can't see who is better, so improvements in your craft rarely reach the moment they decide. Your falling margin is usually telling you how many providers now look like you, and the fix is in how you are positioned rather than in more polish.
- How do I stand out in a crowded market without cutting my price?
- Change what the buyer compares you with. If they line you up against providers who all say the same thing, price becomes the only difference they can see, so narrow who the offer is for and build something that can't be compared on the old terms.
- How do I know if my market is getting crowded?
- Watch for your margin falling while your skill rises, and for buyers repeatedly comparing you on price because they can't tell providers apart. One bad month with a one-off cause is noise, while a pattern that keeps repeating is the market telling you it has moved.